Motor TrendIf you just want an inexpensive, basic universal floor mat to provide some protection for your car’s carpet or spruce up an older car on a tight budget, we liked the Motor Trend Odorless Rubber Floor Mats best. Made by Custom Auto Crews, they have a look and feel that belies their low price, and a relatively flat design that makes them easier to clean than more aggressive-looking mats we tested. But like other inexpensive mats, they tended to move around more than we’d like and will require periodic adjustment to keep them in place.
Rugged Ridge All TerrainOff-roaders know they’ll eventually track a mess back into the cabin of their vehicle, which makes Rugged Ridge’s All Terrain Floor Mats an attractive option if you’re looking for protection against mud. Using state-of-the-art technology, these mats are manufactured with an accurate, customized fit for your truck or SUV.
SMARTLINER CustomDesigned to cover SUVs or trucks, these floor mats offer great protection against any kind of spills, stains, and mud. Manufactured from low-density polyethylene, these are eco-friendly mats that feature a raised and strengthened lip to keep spills from staining your car’s carpet. There are also tall outer sidewalls that trap fluid before it can spread.
Intro-Tech HexomatIf you want a custom-fit floor mat but don’t want to spend the money on a premium liner, we recommend the Intro-Tech Hexomat, which splits the difference in cost and coverage between a universal mat and a model-specific liner. The Hexomat lacks the higher side walls of liners like our top pick, but it does provide wall-to-wall footwell coverage and a design that helps contain spills.
WeatherTech MatsWeatherTech FloorLiners not only fit perfectly: They're the best at containing spills, are easier to install and remove, and have far more vehicle fits than any of the others. Thoughtful details set the WeatherTech liners apart.